2020

A Solution Focused Brief Therapy Note (Updated)

This is an updated entry from my previous discussion on the topic, which can be found here.

The genesis of this is that I was discussing recently with a friend and colleague, former professor, mentor, and one of the people who got me started on my path to be a Solution Focused Counselor/Therapist (that’s a lot of titles) what my notes look like as a Solution Focused Brief Therapist in public practice in the United States where, especially when billing insurance, we must justify our work through documentation, to say nothing of our ethical requirements to document appropriately…so I figured I’d share the template and format I use.

I have come up with the following format for therapeutic interactions which, with the exception of the MSE, I write collaboratively with my patients. This takes no more than five minutes at the end of our session, and ensures I don’t ever get behind on paperwork/case noting.

I do not take any notes during a session in order to foster open and direct communication. There is nothing between myself and the patient (no pad, no pen). This requires a great amount of practice in active listening. I recommend a lot of role play to become comfortable with the technique.

Below is an example of a contrived session I made up about John Doe, it should bear no resemblance to anyone living or dead since I just came up with it on the fly, sans-coffee, while waiting for my flight:


MSE:

Patient presented on time, dressed appropriately, appeared alert and well-oriented. There was no evidence of disruption in speech flow or content, memory, or perception. Current mood observed as euthymic with affect congruent to mood. Thoughts were organized and goal-directed. Judgment appeared good, and insight appeared moderate.

Patient presented with:
– Desire to reduce symptoms is depression;
– Desire to reduce symptoms is anxiety;
– Desire to improve capability for regulating moods/emotions;
– Desire to reduce stressors regarding family;
– Desire to reduce stressors related to work.

Clinical Note:
WBTW (What’s Better This Week): John Doe shared that this week he was able to get out of bed and go to classes twice. John shared that he was also able to wash half of the dishes in his sink.

BHFTS (Best Hopes For Today’s Session): John shared that if he could work on finding a way to attend his classes, and finish doing his dishes, then today’s session would be helpful, useful, and productive.

Scaling (1-10/Zombies-to-Unicorns): 4.5; Goal (1-10): 5/John shared that he will be at a 5 when he is able to do all of the dishes and is able to go to all of his classes.

Discernment: John and this writer discussed barriers to doing his dishes and to attending classes, and how these barriers are negatively impacting his mental health symptoms**.

Exceptions: John shared that the problem of doing dishes and cleaning in general is not a problem when he comes right home after work. John shared that attending classes weren’t an issue when he got more sleep.

Experiment: John was able to brainstorm ways in which he can address his barriers to move to a 5 on the scale. John will try to do dishes twice this week right after work. John decided he will set a reminder on his phone to go off part way through his commute to remind him. John will set his bedtime back by an hour to get an extra hour of sleep.

Clinical/Psychoeducation: This writer provided psychoeducation on the importance of sleep hygiene and behavioral activation for reducing the sxs of depression.

Risk Assessment: John denied thoughts, plans, or intents or harming himself or others.

Follow Up: Follow up in two weeks. John to complete experiment as outlined above. John will call/come in if he requires additional support between now and his next appointment.


**While problem talk is discouraged, linking the patients concerns, and treatment to their mental health symptoms in discussion is necessary for ethical treatment under insurance. This is possible even in SFBT when we look at the “preferred future” (i.e. “I won’t be so anxious,” or “I won’t be as depressed,” etc.). We have to show how they are negatively impacting mental health symptoms because that is the structure of the medical/insurance setup in the United States.

In any event, I hope this is helpful to the wider SFBT community who is forced to balance SFBT work and insurance (without which, only the wealthy could afford our services), and I look forward to turning this into some kind of presentation at some point (SFBT & Insurance: An Uneasy Truce?).

Personal Statement on Today’s Rally of Social Workers and Human Service Professionals in Support of Black Lives Matter

Friday, June 12, 2020

Personal Statement on Today’s Rally of Social Workers and Human Service Professionals in Support of Black Lives Matter

THE VIEWS EXPRESSED HEREIN ARE ENTIRELY MY OWN AND DO NOT REPRESENT ANY OF MY EMPLOYERS: PAST, PRESENT, OR FUTURE.

6. Social Workers’ Ethical Responsibilities to the Broader Society

6.01 Social Welfare

Social workers should promote the general welfare of society, from local to global levels, and the development of people, their communities, and their environments. Social workers should advocate for living conditions conducive to the fulfillment of basic human needs and should promote social, economic, political, and cultural values and institutions that are compatible with the realization of social justice.

6.04 Social and Political Action

(d) Social workers should act to prevent and eliminate domination of, exploitation of, and discrimination against any person, group, or class on the basis of race, ethnicity, national origin, color, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, age, marital status, political belief, religion, immigration status, or mental or physical ability.

(NASW Code of Ethics)

Today my colleagues will be rallying in front of City Hall in support of Black Lives Matter. I am there with them completely in spirit, though, unfortunately not in body: as someone who is Disabled, with chronic-illness, and two auto-immune conditions, and who is immunosuppressed, it is, unfortunately, not safe for me to be in large crowds right now due to COVID-19, even while wearing a face mask.

That said, to remain silent is to side with the oppressor against the oppressed. My field, my profession, can and does do a lot of good. However, the field of Social Work and those who work within it it also must work to de-colonize ourselves, and to de-link ourselves from systems of oppression, so that we are not the “friendlier face” of the police force, or the “friendlier face” of the State’s arm of enforcement and systemic racism and oppression.

My field, like all ‘helping’ fields, has much to answer for: from Orphan Trains in the United States, to the treatment of the indigenous populations in the United States, New Zealand and Canada, and more. We must do better. We must align ourselves with actively anti-racist practices, and we must do the work to educate ourselves, rather than rely on marginalized colleagues to take the work of educating us on their shoulders. We must remove barriers to diversifying our field, and we must work to ensure that those who have been kept out of leadership are placed in roles where they can lead and have their voices heard.

I propose no answers, and no solutions: we are no one’s saviors. Instead, I join together with my brothers and sisters in radical solidarity for tearing down systems of oppression, and replacing them with systems of healing, equity, justice, education, peace, housing, healthcare, and food security.

Yours in the Struggle,

Matthew L. Schwartz

On Being in Awe

As I began to complete treatment plans for my patients (while currently suspended as a necessity by the Office of Mental Health, I had decided I’d rather keep them current, so I don’t have a metric ton of paperwork to do when that requirement comes back in full force). Anyway, I was reflecting on how hard it can be to hold a healing space for my patients in the whirlwind of this crisis. Being a healer takes energy. And we work so hard to avoid burnout.

However, as I went through and began to review the 40 or so treatment plans I wanted to bring up to date and saw the incredible progress, and growth, and resilience, and strength of my patients, I felt this wonderful and incredible sense of awe come over me and I felt so refreshed and so recharged.

I realized that I am continually in awe. I am in awe of humanity. I am in awe of the power to overcome trauma. I am in awe of the ability to overcome torment and torture. I am in awe of our ability to battle our own minds. I am in awe of our ability to hold ourselves up and together amid countless storms. I am in awe of the holiness that exists between each of us when we work to heal one another.

I am in awe of the laughter that exists amidst tears. I am in awe of the ability to be surprised. I am in awe of recovery and the power to mend and to heal. I am in awe for the power to take apart and to separate and to move forward alone. I am in awe at the love that one another can show to total strangers. I am in awe when someone learns how to fall in love with themselves again after years of self-hate.

I am in awe of the universe and the power of community and networks, big and small: from the anthill to the cosmos. I am in awe at our individuality among our interconnectedness.

I am in awe at our individual and collective resilience.

“There is nothing as straight as a crooked ladder.” The Rebbe of Kotsk

And back to blogging (or how I shut down my private practice and resumed the act of using social media as an extension of my Social Work practice), and what the implications of that are.

One of the first parts of personal collateral damage during the immediate COVID-19 pandemic was my private practice. New York State allows those licensed at the LMSW to function (within the scope of their practice) to hold a private practice. I enjoyed that privilege, while also having a wonderful public practice. However, I found it both 1) untenable and 2) unethical to move into telehealth and to be, in essence, in competition with my Public Practice agency. My private practice, while not clinical, should not ever have the possibility of being construed as such. That left not much choice. However, in these times, we have to make the rightest choice, and since we have to socially distance, the rightest choice was to close up shop, and so the choice was made.

When I was first hired at my agency, our CEO let us know at our new hire orientation that the best practice was to lock down and close off our social media. I – vocally – raised my hand and shared that I had professional profiles set up as extensions of my practice and that my Social Work practice extended to the internet, and that I didn’t really plan on closing off that aspect of myself. My CEO warned me that if this was the case, that I would be held responsible for what I said and did online. I shared that I was, quite literally, fine with that. I’m very much okay with being held to account for my words. That remains as true today, as it does almost two years ago now when I started with the agency where I have developed and built and nurtured my public practice.

This does not mean that I don’t have a private social media presence – I have a very well detailed social media policy about just that. It’s for a lot of really good reasons, among them guidance from the University at Buffalo School of Social Work, and the National Association of Social Workers on the use of Technology. It’s also because I like to have a good work/life balance, and I don’t want articles on Trauma-Informed Care to come up when I’m looking at my Gamer/Gaming handle (#ThatGaymerLifeTho). Guess what? I’m okay with being held to account for my words there. Words and actions matter.

I have been a prolific journaler my whole life, and many of those entries are here, saved from the great LiveJournal/Russia-gate (they are behind a protective wall because they would be inappropriate to share at this juncture in my life). I was inspired by visiting Freud’s office on my last trip to Vienna (one of my second homes). Not that I view myself as Freud (or make the comparison) but I was moved by his boldness and bravery in the combination of the personal and private of his writings being displayed together, and it convinced me to move past part of my own propensity to compartmentalize all aspects of my life. That said, writings will be shared as appropriate, and it’s in my will that upon my passing all of my writings will be made open/unrestricted in the hopes that some poor grad student will come along, and among the academese and the flotsam and jetsam and remember that all of us are just people.

So the implications are now that, I continue – as I always have been – to be responsible for myself, my actions (my behavior, my responses to others’ behavior), and my words online and in person, and now I feel a sense of obligation to write, and to produce, and and to generate information that is useful. I also feel the obligation to use this as a sort of…virtual office…not in any way to see patients, or to provide “advice” (which Solution Focused Brief Therapists don’t do, as a rule, and no good therapist should do period)…but as a place to be virtually accessible to colleagues….a Salon for ideas.

To that end, I now have the benefit to returning to using this space not for marketing, but as a vessel to think, to ponder, to consider, to write, to ideate, to share, to postulate, to hypotheize, to think, and to be; so with the death of my private practice, welcome to the rebirth of my digital social work presence.

Welcome, please make yourself comfortable, and take a moment to connect with your breath. You are safe here. You belong here. No matter where you are on your life’s journey, I am happy that you’ve decided to join me here.