I was asked (and honored) to write something for my friend to read before the Kaddish at the Kesher Conference which was held a few weeks ago in Florida; below is what I wrote and was read. I was asked what it means to be a Gay Jew. Given the situation in Israel at the moment, I find it timely to post what I wrote:
People often ask me how I fit into the Jewish Community and how I fit into the Gay Community, can I fit into both at the same time…isn’t it a contradiction?
I state this emphatically, no.
I am 10% of ½ of 1% of the world’s population
and I am proud of my heritages.
When I attend Kol Nidrei services every year, tears stroll down my cheeks, and my eyes turn red from crying and I physically tremble in Awe of the Lord for it is at this time of the year when the gates of heaven are open, and even the hosts of heaven are judged, that I feel at one with God and who I am.
I do not say Kol Nidrei just for Jews around the world who have to lie about who they are because it is too dangerous to proclaim their faith. I say Kol Nidrei for those who are in the closet as well. I say Kol Nidrei for those who – if they came out – would be slain. I say Kol Nidrei for all the souls I met in the West Village who live on the street because their parents broke their vow of “I’ll love you forever, no matter what.” I say Kol Nidrei for my friends who have had to lie to their parents and say that they’ll never bring home a boyfriend again, because they’re the quarter back on the football team and a Jock can’t be Queer… ‘not in this family’, ‘not my son’.
As I stand before the Ark, I present myself to God as I am and without pretense. When I am questioned about my sexuality by others I answer simply that “if God has a problem with who I love, than he should have made me straight, if he still has a problem with it, he can wrestle me in my tent, but I will not stand before the Ark and lie about who I love, I will not commit a transgression before the eye’s of the lord.”
Have I felt discrimination from the Jewish community at times? Yes, of course. And when these people tell me that I’m an abomination, that by being truthful, that by loving my boyfriend, that living an honest life and making an honest living I’m living in sin all I can say is “WHAT ABOUT MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS WHO BORE THE WEIGHT OF THE PINK AND BLACK TRIANGLE!? What about us!? Were we not identical as skeletons at the gates of the camps? Did our skin not burn the same as yours when we were murdered? Did our blood not bleed the same crimson red when we were shot as the Nazis used us, together, as target practice? Did we not waste away just the same as we were herded like cattle onto the trains? Did our souls not rise up to heaven together through plumes of black smoke, on the backs of angels, to the sky? Did our deaths together at the ghetto uprisings mean nothing to you? Are we not all created in the image of God? Do we not all return to dust?
Ani L’Dodi, V’Dodi Li – I am my beloveds and my beloveds is mine.
The world is a scary place and when you say you are a Jew you take on a responsibility. When you say that you are Gay, you do the same. But when you embrace God, when you feel the eternal flame burning within you, when the letters of the Torah jump out at you and when Hatikvah is sung you feel something in your core tremble and you know that you are in the presence of the divine…then…then you know you have found home, you walk without fear, without the judgment of others, because then you know the judgment of the one person who matters most and he’s telling you to go forth, to live life, to love.
This is what it means to be Gay and Jewish.